About Us

Play It Again Sports has locations in Carmel and Fishers that are locally owned and operated. We focus on serving the community while providing exceptional customer service. We buy, sell, and trade used and new sports equipment and fitness gear. We specialize in fitness and exercise equipment, football, baseball, softball, volleyball, ice and field hockey, lacrosse, bicycles, track and field, winter sports, and soccer.

Sustainable

When you bring in your quality used gear, it prevents them from filling up landfills and puts cash in your pocket.

Affordable

We have tons of quality used and new gear from your favorite brands at affordable prices.

Convenient

We make it easy to buy and sell gear for all sports and fitness, all day, every day, with no appointment necessary.