About Us
Locally owned. Here to help.
Play It Again Sports Kings Auto Mall is independently owned and operated by local business owners. We buy and sell quality used and new sports and fitness gear, so families can save money and good equipment stays in play.
Your neighborhood sports store
From first seasons to travel teams, we help athletes and families across Greater Cincinnati gear up for less. Our staff will help you find the right fit, and when you've outgrown it, we'll buy it back.
Proudly serving Cincinnati, Kings, Mason, West Chester, Lebanon and beyond.
Why shop with us
Brands we carry: New and used gear from Rawlings, Easton, Wilson and Franklin (baseball and softball); Titleist, TaylorMade, Callaway, Ping, Cleveland and Srixon (golf); Innova, MVP, Discraft, Dynamic Discs and Westside (disc golf); STX, Warrior and Brine (lacrosse); CCM and Bauer (hockey); Spalding and Baden (basketball and volleyball); Cap Barbell (fitness); Burton, Salomon, Rossignol and Elan (snow sports); plus Nike, Adidas, Under Armour, Asics, Everlast, Century, Cutters, Shock Doctor and Champro.
Frequently asked questions
What is your return policy?
New items: Return within 14 days for a refund to the original payment method. Items must be unused and in their original packaging.
Used items: Return within 14 days for store credit only.
The original receipt is required for all returns. No returns are accepted on sale, discounted or clearance items. Those sales are final. Effective January 1, 2027.
Does store credit expire?
Yes. Store credits expire 2 years after the date they are issued, so please use your earned store credits within 2 years. Effective January 1, 2027.
Do I need an appointment to sell my gear?
No. We buy gear all day, every day we're open. Just bring it in. Learn how selling works.
How do I get paid for my gear?
Cash on the spot, or store credit you can use toward anything in the store.
How much will I get for my gear?
Our offer depends on the brand, condition, current demand and how much of that item we already have in stock. Bring it in and we will look it over and make you an offer.
Do you buy everything?
No. We buy quality sports and fitness gear in good working condition, ready for the next athlete. What we take depends on condition, the season and what we already have in stock.
Do you do consignment or buy bikes?
We consign bicycles only, and only April through July. We do not take in bikes the rest of the year. All other gear we buy outright for cash or store credit.
Can I get a quote over the phone?
No. We need to see your gear in person to make an offer. Bring it in any time we are open.
Can I shop your inventory online?
Yes. Much of our inventory is online and updated daily. Shop by sport to see what's in stock.
Do you sell new and used gear?
Both. We carry quality used gear plus new gear from top brands, and our used selection changes every day.
Can I put an item on hold?
Yes, until the end of the next business day, no later. After that the item goes back on the sales floor.
Can I use my store credit at other Play It Again Sports stores?
No. Each Play It Again Sports store is independently owned and operated, so store credit from our store can only be used here.
Do you make custom team uniforms?
Yes. We make Champro custom uniforms for any sport. Our team helps you design, edit and place the order. Most orders take about 3 weeks, rush orders are available, and the minimum is 6 pieces.
What services do you offer?
Baseball and softball glove relacing and golf club regripping. Stop in and ask our team.
Are you hiring?
Check our Jobs page for current openings.