About Us
WHAT WE DO:
At Play It Again Sports, we help you get in the game—without breaking the bank. Whether you're a seasoned pro or just getting started, we’ve got a wide range of quality new and used sports gear, from golf clubs to basketballs, and even snowboard equipment for those who think winter is a sport (we get it, it’s cold, but fun).
Need to upgrade your gear? We've got you covered. Want to trade in your old stuff? We’ll take it off your hands—no questions asked (unless it’s about that ancient bike you’re trying to unload, then we’ll definitely ask why you still have it).
Our team is here to help you find the right gear, because let's face it, the only thing worse than losing a game... is losing it with bad equipment. So come visit us, where we turn “play it again” into “play it better.”
WHY WE DO IT:
At Play It Again Sports, we’re driven by one simple belief: sports should be accessible to everyone. We know that the right gear can make all the difference, but it shouldn’t cost a fortune to get started or stay in the game.
We’re here to provide athletes of all levels with the best possible options—whether you’re looking for top-quality pre-owned gear or brand new equipment that won’t break the bank. Plus, when you trade in your old stuff, you're not just clearing out space at home—you’re making sports more affordable for others, too.
Every game, every practice, every moment on the field or court is a chance to push boundaries and have fun. We’re here to make sure you’ve got the tools to make the most of it.
Contact Us
Need To Talk To Someone Who Knows Sports?
-
Phone:
717-569-1400
Phone:
717-569-1400
-
Email:
pias11477@aol.com (Yes, we know, AOL, Ha Ha)
Email:
pias11477@aol.com (Yes, we know, AOL, Ha Ha)
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
Have Questions? We’ve Got Answers.
From how our buying and trading process works to what gear we carry seasonally, our FAQ section covers the basics. Whether you're shopping, selling, or just curious, you'll find quick answers to the most common questions here. Still need help? Feel free to give us a call or stop by the store — we’re happy to help!
Do I Need To Make An Appointment To Sell Gear?
Nope. We are willing to take a look at we you have at any time.
Do You Take Anything?
No, we don't take just anything. A common misconception is that we will even take your gear that needs to be thrown away due to it not working, in some cases the age, and for sanitary reasons. Keep in mind that we buy is always at the employees discretion!
How Do We Determine What We Pay?
There is a lot that goes into what we will give, and the following is not limiting us in what we use in anyway. And it differs across different items. For example, higher quantity items like cleats we only give $5-$15 cash or store credit due to the thousands we get traded into us each year. For other items we use, past sold items from our store and the internet, an assortment of value guides, we look at what an item sold for new, trends we have seen in store and of course our own experience and a lot more.
Do We Consign Items
No, we do not do consignment.
Do You Only Sell Used?
The most common misconception we get asked. Our store in Lancaster, PA is about a 65-70% NEW store. While the other 30-35% is used.