Sell To Us

Ball Gloves, Baseballs & Softballs, Baseball Apparel, Baseball Bats, Baseball Cleats, Softball Cleats, Bat Bags, Batting Gloves, Batting Helmets, Catchers Gear, Softball Bats, Training Aids

Disc Golf Bags, Disc Golf Goals, Discs

Heavy Bags, Kettlebells, Recumbent Bikes, Resistance Bands, Treadmills, Upright Bikes, Weight Benches, Weights, Yoga Mats

Cleats & Shoes, Apparel, Footballs, Helmets, Practice Jerseys, Pads

Package Sets, Golf Balls, Iron & Hybrid Sets, Junior Club Sets, Proline Drivers, Putters, Shoes, Stand Travel & Cart Bags

Gloves, Goalie Pads, Helmets, Hockey Bags, Pants, Shin Pads, Shoulder Pads, Skates, Sticks

Cleats, Gloves, Goggles, Helmets, Lacrosse Balls, Shoulder Pads, Sticks

Badminton, Balls, Pickleball, Racquetball, Squash, Tennis

Figure Skates, Hockey Skates, Inline Skates, Roller Skates, Soft Boot Skates

Helmets, Skis, Ski Boots, Winter Outerwear, Snowboards, Snowboard Boots, Snowshoes, X-Country Ski Boots, X-Country Skis

Balls, Goals, Shin Pads, Soccer Bags, Soccer Cleats & Indoor Shoes

Contact your local store to learn more about the products and categories they're currently buying!

We buy a wide variety of quality used sports and fitness gear. We buy all day, every day, whatever the season. No need to make an appointment. If a sport is played in our community and there’s demand for it, we buy it. Play It Again Sports stores do not buy or sell firearms of any sort.

It depends. We base our buying prices on brand, condition and demand for the items. Typically we will resell our used items for about 40-60% of what they would sell for new today. You would receive 30-50% of that amount depending on demand, condition and current inventory levels of like products.

Yes, you can! We can pay you on the spot for your items or you can receive an additional incentive if you trade towards new or used products in the store today. Basically, you create your own discount by bringing in items to trade against your purchase.

We can pay you on the spot (either cash or a check, depending upon the amount) or offer you a store credit for trade.

Yes, we buy all sports all day every day, whatever the season. Items that are brought in during or right before their respective season are more valuable to us, and you will receive the best price for them during that timeframe.

All of our stores are individually owned and operated but also purchase new gear and top brands from the same vendors as our competitors. We can offer you the same competitive pricing on new product as the big box locations, and we still give you the individual attention you expect from a locally owned business.

Yes, we do! As long as it meets our buying criteria of brand, condition and demand, we are happy to purchase it. That’s how we get such a great selection of quality used sports and fitness equipment!

We will offer you 10-20% more than what we would pay you directly for your gear if you are spending your money in the store rather than taking cash. Either way – the choice is yours!

We have both used and new product in our inventory. We have new product to fill in the gaps where we do not get enough quality used equipment and to satisfy the customers who would prefer new equipment at a great price. We are always looking for more used sports and fitness equipment; so bring your gear in today, so we can make you an offer!

Most used product is sold in “as is” condition. We rely on our strict buying criteria to ensure that the product we buy is safe and current by today’s standards.

During our business hours, we buy all day, every day - no appointment necessary!

We do purchase used athletic footwear, performance apparel and winter outerwear. The apparel items we purchase are used primarily in sports rather than street wear and are usually made of technical fabrics. The athletic footwear and apparel items we purchase must be gently used, in excellent condition and free from tears or stains.