About Us
Meet your Cartersville team
Our locally owned store helps Cartersville athletes and families find new and used sports equipment at a price that works for them. Come in to shop, sell, trade, or get advice on the gear you need.

Meet the people behind the counter.
John Bemesderfer & Chris Carney
Brothers-in-law and longtime Play It Again Sports operators, John and Chris bring decades of combined experience to the Cartersville store. They share a simple goal: a welcoming, well-organized shop with good gear, fair value, and people ready to help.
Part of the Cartersville community.
Supporting local teams, schools, and first responders is part of being a local sports store.
Cartersville–Bartow Chamber of Commerce
We’re proud to be part of the local business community.

Kraken Fastpitch
Meet Kraken Fastpitch
Cartersville Little League

Bartow Recreation Department

Cass High School

Cartersville High School

Bartow–Cartersville Fire Departments
Teams and organizations we support
Get to know the local programs and organizations we support.

Youth baseball
Cartersville Little League
Visit website
School athletics
Cartersville High School Baseball
Visit website
School athletics
Cass High School Baseball
Visit website
School athletics
Adairsville High School Baseball
Visit website
School athletics
Cass Middle School Soccer
Visit website
School athletics
Cass Middle School Softball
Visit website
Youth baseball
USA Scout Baseball 9U
Visit website
Local sports coverage
Cass Sports Network
Visit website
More organizations and events
- Canes Spring
- FFA Golf Tournament
- Ignite Softball
- The Hive
Past sponsorships
More teams, organizations and events we’ve supported.
- Kraken Softball
- LakePoint Sports
- Acworth 11U
- Smokeshow
- Veterans Event
- 9/11 Memorial Ride
- Canes 12U (Singer)
- Canes 10U (Berrong)
- Cass Basketball
- Disc Golf Tournament
Have gear you no longer use?
Sell it for cash or trade it toward your next purchase. What we buy depends on condition, local demand, and current inventory.

A local store. A local website builder.
Tyler manages the Cartersville store, including our online inventory and store updates. Whether you’re browsing online or stopping by, he helps make the store easy to shop.
Tyler also builds websites through FLM Productions. Looking for a clearer website or a better way for customers to reach your business? Take a look at his work.
Explore FLM Productions410 Cherokee Place · Cartersville, GA 30121