null Skip to main content

About Us

Play It Again Sports Cartersville

Locally Owned. Built Around Gear, Service, and Community.

We help Cartersville athletes, families, coaches, and weekend players find quality new and used sports gear, trade in equipment they no longer need, and get practical help from a local team that stays involved in the community.

John Bemesderfer and Chris Carney from Play It Again Sports Cartersville
John Bemesderfer & Chris Carney Brothers-in-law, local owners, and longtime Play It Again Sports operators.

Your local sports store

Not A Big Box. A Better Gear Shop.

John Bemesderfer and Chris Carney are brothers-in-law with decades of combined Play It Again Sports experience and a lifetime around sports. John started with the brand as a young team member in Florida, and Chris later managed stores of his own before they took over the Cartersville location.

The goal is simple: keep the store clean, organized, useful, and easy to shop. From stronger inventory and fair trade-in value to repair services, custom orders, and real help from people who know the local sports scene, Play It Again Sports Cartersville is built to be the kind of store families want to come back to.

Buy. Sell. Trade. Turn quality used gear into cash, credit, or your next upgrade.
New & Used Gear Daily-changing inventory across the sports Cartersville families play most.
Real Services Glove work, bat wraps, club regripping, kayak rentals, and more.
Organized Floor A cleaner, easier shopping experience with better inventory and help close by.

What makes us different

Built For The Way Local Athletes Actually Shop.

Inventory changes, seasons move fast, and families need options. We keep the focus on useful gear, honest value, and service that helps you leave ready to play.

Trade-In Value

Bring in quality used sports and fitness equipment. We will take a look and help turn unused gear into cash, store credit, or room for the next season.

Useful Gear Services

Need a glove worked on, a bat rewrapped, a club regripped, or help finding something specific? The Cartersville team is here for the practical details.

Community First

John and Chris stay present in the same leagues, fields, teams, and local events their customers care about. That local connection shapes how the store serves Cartersville families.

Store operations & online support

Keeping The Store Easy To Shop.

Tyler is the manager and web developer for Play It Again Sports Cartersville, and his role adds to the family-run feel behind the store. He helps keep the operation moving day to day while also maintaining the local website, product listings, and promotions that help customers see what is happening before they stop in.

Whether he is working behind the counter, improving the site, or helping customers find the right gear, the focus stays the same: keep the store useful, organized, and connected to the Cartersville sports community.

Store supportHelps keep daily operations moving.
Online inventorySupports listings, pages, and promotions.
Customer helpConnects shoppers with the right gear.
Tyler from Play It Again Sports Cartersville

Great gear deserves another season

Bring In The Gear You Are Done Using.

Quality used sports equipment can help another local athlete get in the game for less. Bring it by the store and we will review it for cash or trade value.

Start Your Trade-In Shop Used Gear