Play It Again Sports buys and sells quality used sports and fitness gear. Bring in your quality used gear and get paid on the spot, or trade up for the gear you need now. Our staff members are trained to provide athletes with the best possible fit in all categories.

We buy gear all day, every day, with no appointment necessary. Each location is individually owned and operated, so it is easy to support local while shopping sustainably and affordably.

Visit our store or shop online!

Meet The Owners

In April 2014, Hillary and Doug Mantelli acquired Play It Again Sports Castle Rock and have continued the tradition as the community's preferred new & used sporting goods store. With Play It Again Sports, customers can enjoy the benefits of working with a locally-owned company operated by members of the community. Additionally, as part of a nationwide chain, we can leverage tremendous buying power to achieve the most competitive prices for your family.